Happy Holidays from the Quality Heating & Cooling Family! Read More

Skip navigation

Give us a call 24/7

845-343-6650

How to Decide Whether to Repair or Replace Your Heating System

woman-uses-laptop

Homeowners depend on their heating systems to keep their homes warm, cozy, and safe during our cold, winter, weather. If you have an older heating system, your utility costs are high, and you’ve needed repairs more often, you might be wondering whether your system will need to be replaced soon. When to repair a heating system and when to replace it entirely is a dilemma every homeowner has faced.  

While repairs may offer a quicker fix, there are times when replacing the system is the wiser long-term solution. This guide will help you weigh the key factors to make an informed decision on heating installation in Middletown. For a limited time, we are offering $500 off a new HVAC installation along with a 1-year Maintenance Club agreement.

Guide to deciding between repairing or replacing your heating system

When to Repair Your Heating System

If your heating system is still relatively new or has only minor issues, a repair may be the most practical option. Here are some signs that a repair could be sufficient.

  • Age of the System: A good rule of thumb is that systems under 8 years old are often worth repairing if they’ve received regular maintenance. In general, furnaces and heat pumps have a lifespan of 10-15 years if they’ve received annual tune-ups. If your system is well under that range, repairing it is usually the preferred option.
  • Minor Issues: Not every problem warrants a complete replacement. Common minor issues are generally manageable with a repair. If your heating system is otherwise reliable, these small fixes can extend its life without requiring a major overhaul.
  • Repair Cost Relative to Replacement: A key factor in deciding whether to repair or replace is the cost of the repair. If the repair cost is less than 50% of the cost of a new system, repairing it can be a smart choice. When calculating the costs, it’s important to consider both the immediate expense of the repair and any potential future repairs that may arise due to the age or condition of the system.

When to Replace Your Heating System

In some cases, replacement is a better option than continuing to pay for repairs on a system that is nearing the end of its lifespan. Here are some scenarios when it might make sense to invest in a new heating system.

  • System Age and Efficiency: As heating systems approach the 10-15 years age range they tend to lose efficiency and become more prone to breakdowns–especially if they haven’t received maintenance every year. 
  • Frequent Repairs: If your system needs a repair and you’re not sure if that money would be better spent on a new system, an easy rule to follow is the “50/50 rule.” If repair costs add up to more than 50% of the cost of a new system, replacement often makes more sense. 
  • High Energy Bills: If you’ve noticed a consistent increase in heating costs even with regular maintenance, the system’s inefficiency may be to blame. Upgrading to an energy-efficient model will significantly reduce heating expenses.

If you’re not sure your system needs repair or replacement, we will give you an honest opinion and recommend the best course of action for your home and budget.

Contact Quality Heating & Cooling today for heating installation in Middletown, NY. It’s not a Quality job, unless it has our Quality seal.

Comments are closed.